Big Papi skeptical steroids helped Bonds in chase
ESPN.com - MLB - Big Papi skeptical steroids helped Bonds in chase
Count David Ortiz among those who isn't convinced Barry Bonds used illegal performance-enhancing drugs -- or if they really helped the San Francisco Giants outfielder make his run at Hank Aaron's home run record."To hit the ball, the guy makes it look easy, but it ain't. I don't know how you can have that swing, consistently. I don't know how steroids can do that," Ortiz told the Boston Herald. "There are supposed to be guys using steroids in the game, and there's nobody close to Barry Bonds. What's that mean? He was using the best [stuff]? Know what I'm saying?"
I've always been a little skeptical of the claim that steroids help ball players hit home runs. While steroids do help you recover from weight lifting more quickly, in baseball, you can become too muscular. Flexibility is a key factor in bat speed, which is what really drives the ball a distance. I can't remember the player's name, but there was someone back in the early 90's, I think with the Texas Rangers, who was playing well, bulked up suddenly (which everyone assumed to be steroids), and his performance fell off a cliff because he was too muscular. Or think of Lenny Dykstra. Yeah, he was great in 1993, but he was never the same due to injuries afterwards.
And, as Big Papi points out, Bonds is doing something nobody else does. Also, he's still doing it this now that steroid testing is in place, and he's coming off an injury. I find it much more likely that he's just a genetic freak who's taking full advantage of our nutritional and exercise knowledge.



Comments
While I agree that bat swing is critical, the sheer force Bonds brings to the ball is the issue. He only needs flexibility in the most narrow sense. This is not yoga or anything. We're talking about muscle memory to bring a bat from behind you, forward. Look at the before and after pictures of Bonds. Ain't no way you're gonna convince me he wasn't doing steroids.
FWIW, I have no doubt this post would be vastly different if Bonds were a Yankee.
Posted by: Duffy | May 8, 2007 1:00 PM
I've defended Yankees against charges of steroid use. (Jeter, ARod, Clemens.) Not Giambi, obviously.
I hate the Yankees, but I'm not going to misrepresent what I believe to be the truth to do it. There's enough honest reasons to hate them that I don't need to make up stuff.
Posted by: Paul Smith | May 8, 2007 2:15 PM
Fair enough. I stand corrected.
Posted by: Duffy | May 10, 2007 7:47 AM