Delaware
Conservative
Bloggers
Alliance
DCBA Logo
Delaware Blogs

Catholic Blogs

Conservative
Blogs

Catholic
B-Team
Catholic B-Team Bloggers Logo

Prolife Blogs
Friends

"I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate."
--Romans 7:15 (RSV)



Catholics Against Rudy

« October 2007 | Main | December 2007 »

November 30, 2007

More Weekend Reading (Plus Arinze Rocks!)

The US Bishops have issued a document on liturgical music. Hopefully this will help clean up some of the problems we currently have.

Also, Cardinal Arinze on liturgical dance:

Dance is not known in the Latin Rite of the Mass. Our congregation [for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments] has considered it for years. There is no major document of the Church on dance, but the directive we give from our congregation is this: In the strict liturgy -- that means the Mass, the sacraments -- Europe and America should not talk of liturgical dance at all because dance as known in Europe and North America is not part of worship. So they should forget it and not talk about it at all.

But, it is different in Africa and Asia: not a concession to them, but because their culture is different. If you give a typical African the gifts to bring at Offertory, and you give a typical Eur the same gifts to bring, if they don't see one another: the European will be rather stiff in walking to the altar; the African is likely to have movement, right, left. It is not a dance, it is a graceful movement to show joy and offering. Also in Asia they have refined movements showing respect, adoration, joy. In Africa all the cultures are not the same. If you are in Ashanti in Ghana, they have some refined movements.

The Bishops of each country have to watch this, knowing that the aim, the reason for Mass, the reasons are four: adoration, contrition, thanksgiving, and asking for what we need. If the movements help towards that, yes; if they do not, no. Now, if you say dance in Europe and North America, people think of Saturday evening, ballroom dance: one man, one woman. And it is all right as recreation. But we do not come to Mass to enjoy, we don't come to Mass to admire people, and clap for them, and say "Repeat! Repeat! Wonderful! Excellent!" That is all right for the auditorium, for the theater, even for the parish hall... presuming that the dance is acceptable from a moral point of view. Because there are some dances that are wrong everywhere, even in the parish hall and in the theater, because they are provocative unnecessarily. And also in Africa and Asia, every dance is not acceptable. There are some dances that are totally not acceptable in any religious event.

So it differs. But as for North America or Europe, we think that the dance should not enter the liturgy at all, and the people discussing liturgical dance should spend that time saying the Rosary. [laughter and applause] Or they should spend that time reading one of the documents of the Pope on the Holy Eucharist. We have already enough problems; why banalize more, why desacralize more? Haven't we already enough confusion? If you want to admire a dance, you know where to go. But not Mass.(partial transcript from here)

If only he weren't so old, he could be our next Pope. That would be great.

Fred Thompson: The Candidate of Ideas

Kimberley Strassel:

[Thompson]'s proposed revitalizing America's armed forces by increasing the core defense budget, building up a million-member ground force, and instituting sweeping missile defense. He went where no other GOP candidate has yet gone with a detailed plan to shore up Social Security, by changing the benefits formula and offering voluntary "add on" accounts for younger workers. He would re-energize school vouchers. His border security blueprint certainly matches Mitt Romney's or Rudy Giuliani's in its, ahem, creativity and thoroughness.

This week's tax proposal was decidedly fresh, going beyond the run-of-the-mill candidate promise to extend the Bush tax cuts, and calling for the end of the death tax and the AMT, a cut in the corporate tax rate and even a voluntary flat tax. According to a campaign source, in upcoming weeks Mr. Thompson will unveil plans to reduce federal spending by limiting nondefense growth to inflation, earmark reform, and a one-year freeze on the hiring of non-essential civilian workers and contractors.

There's plenty here to get conservative voters and bloggers and pundits engaged in some healthy, even lively, debate. That is, if they'd heard any of this. Most haven't, and for that Mr. Thompson has mostly himself to blame.

I think Thompson's biggest problem in this campaign is his late start. Not because it allowed other candidates to set the tone or attract the voters, but because the top campaign talent and activists were locked in. The only truly experienced national campaign staffers were those fired by McCain back during his campaign's cost-cutting days, so, with no disrespect to those people, there wasn't a large quantity of talent out there. When you add in that most of the party activists in New Hampshire and Iowa plus fundraisers were committed, there wasn't much for Thompson left to pick from in assembling an organization.

Which is a shame, because he's the only candidate in this race talking about ideas, putting forth policies that really could change things. The good news is that many voters are still making up their minds about who to support, even in the early primary states. Rush Limbaugh's non-endorsement of Thompson today should help a great deal also.

So, yeah, I'm a Fred Head.

Top 100 Movies Meme

There a meme going around using AFI's 100 Years... 100 Movies list. Bear in mind, I'm not a big movie fan.

5 favorite movies on the list:
1. Star Wars
2. Raiders of the Lost Ark
3. Pulp Fiction
4. Patton
5. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid

5 movies on the list I didn't like
1. The Graduate
2. 2001: A Space Oddessy
3. Close Encounters of the Third Kind
4. Wuthering Heights
5. ET: The Extra Terrestial

5 on the list that I haven't Seen, but Want To
1. The Third Man
2. The Manchurian Candidate
3. Citizen Kane
4. Psycho
5. Vertigo

5 on the list that I haven't seen, and no interest in seeing
1. Platoon
2. Annie Hall
3. Dances with Wolves
4. Dr. Strangelove
5. Schindler's List

5 favorites that aren't on the list
1. Die Hard
2. The Great Escape
3. Airplane!
4. Bull Durham
5. The Passion of the Christ

Fred Thompson Ad

He's the only person whose conservatism I trust left in the GOP field. At least among the credible candidates. This video shows some of the reasons I don't trust the others.

The encyclical is up!

"Spe salvi" Encyclical Letter of His Holiness Benedict XVI on Christian Hope

I hope to read it this weekend, probably Sunday.

Quote of the Day

"Is there no virtue among us? If there be not, we are in a wretched situation. No theoretical checks-no form of government can render us secure. To suppose that any form of government will secure liberty or happiness without any virtue in the people, is a chimerical idea, if there be sufficient virtue and intelligence in the community, it will be exercised in the selection of these men. So that we do not depend on their virtue, or put confidence in our rulers, but in the people who are to choose them."

-- James Madison (speech at the Virginia Ratifying Convention, 20 June 1788)

Reference: The True Republican, French, ed. (28-29)

November 29, 2007

Henry Hyde, RIP

Long-time Congressman Henry Hyde passed away last night. He was one of the first national politicians I took a shine to when I began becoming interested in politics as a kid. I haven't always seen eye to eye with him on all issues (gun control), but I admired him for his strong devotion to the weakest members of our society: the unborn. The Amendment that came to be named after him (the Hyde Amendment obviously) which prohibited the national government from paying for abortions. Who knows how many lives this saved? In terms of lives saved, he has to be one of the great humanitarians of our time. In recognition of his long service to our country, he was recently awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom.

America's lost a good one.

National Review.com on Henry Hyde

I do have to agree with much of his take on the 2008 Presidential race:

So what does Hyde think about the 2008 presidential field? On John McCain: “He’s interesting and unpredictable but I think he’s electable and correct on social issues.” On Rudy Giuliani: “I like him and he’s electable, but he’s dead wrong on the life issue and that invalidates his candidacy for me.” Mitt Romney: “I don’t know enough about him but he sounds promising.” Then there’s Hyde’s House colleague, Duncan Hunter: “He’s a good man but he’s too protectionist.” Asked about George Pataki, he simply snarls. And what about Barack Obama? He’s not a Republican, but he’s from Hyde’s hometown: “I’ve never seen anyone with such a slim record receive such adulation. He seems like a nice and capable man, but he’s being treated as Pericles revisited or something.”

Eternal rest grant unto him, O Lord, and may his soul and all the souls of the faithful departed, through the mercy of God, rest in peace.

Nerdy Pickup Lines

Bloggasm: Was it good for you? サ 50 nerdy pick-up lines

My favorites:

2. I wish I was your derivative so I could lie tangent to your curves.

15. Baby I’ll treat you like my homework — I’ll slam you on the table and do you all night long

22. By looking at you I can tell you’re 36-25-36, which by the way are all perfect squares.

23. It doesn’t take a genius to see how gorgeous you are, but if it did, I would be overqualified. (This one made me laugh out loud.)

Hat Tip: Instapundit.com

Late shift work is linked to cancer

Late shift work is linked to cancer - Yahoo! News

Next month, the International Agency for Research on Cancer, the cancer arm of the World Health Organization, will classify shift work as a "probable" carcinogen.

That will put shift work in the same category as cancer-causing agents like anabolic steroids, ultraviolet radiation, and diesel engine exhaust.
...
It is a surprising twist for an idea that scientists first described as "wacky," said Richard Stevens, a cancer epidemiologist and professor at the University of Connecticut Health Center. In 1987, Stevens published a paper suggesting a link between light at night and breast cancer.

Back then, he was trying to figure out why breast cancer incidence suddenly shot up starting in the 1930s in industrialized societies, where nighttime work was considered a hallmark of progress. Most scientists were bewildered by his proposal.

But in recent years, several studies have found that women working at night for many years are indeed more prone to breast cancer, and that animals who have their light-dark schedules switched grow more cancerous tumors and die quicker.

Some research has also shown that men working at night may have a higher rate of prostate cancer.

Because these studies have been done mainly in nurses and airline crews, bigger studies in different populations are needed to confirm or disprove the findings.
...
Even worse than working the night shift would be to frequently flip between day and night shifts.

"The problem is re-setting your body's clock," said Aaron Blair, of the United States' National Cancer Institute, who chaired IARC's recent meeting on shift work. "If you worked at night and stayed on it, that would be less disruptive than constantly changing shifts."

Anyone whose light and dark schedule was frequently disrupted — including frequent long-haul travelers or insomniacs — could theoretically face the same increased cancer risks, Stephens said.

Scientists are now trying to figure out what might be possible to reduce shift workers' risk of developing cancer. Melatonin can be taken as a supplement, but experts don't recommend taking it long-term, since that could ruin the body's ability to produce it naturally.

November 28, 2007

Quote-a-palooza

"The big news over the weekend was that a guy named Kevin Rudd won the election to be the Prime Minister of Australia. Rudd is the leader of the Labor Party and beat the incumbent John Howard whose Conservative Party had been in power for nearly 12 years. This was, of course, reported around the world as a defeat for... George Bush. EVERYTHING is reported around the world as a defeat for... George Bush." - Rich Galen

"The pessimists and defeatists who declared the surge doomed and said we were digging ourselves into a deeper hole have been proven wrong. The story of Iraq now is that terrorists have been killed, captured or driven out of territory retaken and cleansed by American and Iraqi forces- a coalition that has stabilized much of the country." - Donald Lambro

"No one contends that the other Amendments that preserve rights of ‘the people' - the First, Fourth, Ninth and Tenth- do not preserve individuals' rights. The same must be true of the Second." - Jed Babbin

"If a CEO of a fortune 500 company were to retire, would anyone seriously consider his wife to be an adequate replacement simply because she was married to him when he ran the company?" - John Hawkins

"If you don't like going to the DMV, imagine if the only place you could go to resolve a health care problem is some government agency." - Rush Limbaugh

"Courage is almost a contradiction in terms. It means a strong desire to live taking the form of readiness to die." - Gilbert Keith Chesterton

"Facts do not cease to exist because they are ignored." - Aldous Huxley

"A man who thinks of himself as belonging to a particular national group in America has not yet become an American. And the man who goes among you to trade upon your nationality is no worthy son to live under the Stars and Stripes." - Woodrow Wilson

"Americans are so enamored of equality, they would rather be equal in slavery than unequal in freedom." - Alexis de Tocqueville

"Politics ain't worrying this country one-tenth as much as trying to find a parking spot." - Will Rogers

"The problem with the process is obvious: It is getting harder for candidates not beloved by the national media and party establishments to compete. The solution, alas, is rather elusive. One thing is clear: If in 2012, the major parties choose 80 percent of their convention delegates on a single day the media breathlessly describes as ‘Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious Tuesday,' we will be headed in the wrong direction." - W. James Antle III

"The plain truth is that if guys like [Leonardo] DiCaprio, [George] Clooney and Robert Redford, were women, they'd be called bimbos." - Burt Prelutsky

Words to watch for

There are some words that just set me off and let me know that the person speaking is not worth my attention:

  • Multi-cultural
  • Diverse
  • Holistic
  • Hueristic
  • Best Practices
  • Action Items
  • Fellowship (especially when used as a verb)
  • Dynamic (outside computer code)
  • "Do you have the bandwidth to take this on?" (Why not just ask if I have the time?)
  • Any non-mocking reference to a mission statement

These drive me crazy.

Chávez threatens opponents

The Venezuelan president, Hugo Chávez, today threatened to strip the country's industrialists of their assets if they continued to oppose his indefinite presidency. ... Human rights groups, the Catholic church and other opponents warn that revisions to the constitution will concentrate power in Chávez 's hands - charges that government allies dismiss as rhetoric from an economic elite afraid to lose privileges as the country moves toward socialism.

Yesterday Chávez said he was freezing relations with Colombia after Uribe halted his attempts to reach out to the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (Farc), leftwing guerrillas who have waged a bloody civil war against the Colombian state for decades.

Source

Nope, no danger of a dictatorship here.

Hat Tip: JammieWearingFool

November 27, 2007

Chavez vows referendum 'cannot fail'

Chavez vows referendum 'cannot fail' - Yahoo! News

Rallies for and against constitutional changes proposed by President Hugo Chavez surged Tuesday as the Venezuelan leader declared that a weekend referendum on the proposed charter "cannot fail."

Given Chavez's history of less than stellar concern for democracy, can we really deny that this statement is a promise, rather a rallying cry? That he'll make sure it passes, regardless of the actual results?

A "liberal" priest celebrates the Tridentine Mass

The Cafeteria Is Closed: A liberal priest celebrates his first TLM

The old Missal’s rubrical micromanagement made me feel like a mere machine, devoid of personality; but, I wondered, is that really so bad? I actually felt liberated from a persistent need to perform, to engage, to be forever a friendly celebrant. When I saw a photo of the old Latin Mass in our local newspaper, I suddenly recognized the rite’s ingenious ability to shrink the priest. Shot from the choir loft, I was a mere speck of green, dwarfed by the high altar. The focal point was not the priest but the gathering of the people. And isn’t that a valid image of the church, the people of God?

The act of praying the Roman Canon slowly and in low voice accented my own smallness and mere instrumentality more than anything else. Plodding through the first 50 or so words of the Canon, I felt intense loneliness. As I moved along, however, I also heard the absolute silence behind me, 450 people of all ages praying, all bound mysteriously to the words I uttered and to the ritual actions I haltingly and clumsily performed. Following the consecration, I fell into a paradoxical experience of intense solitude as I gazed at the Sacrament and an inexplicable feeling of solidarity with the multitude behind me.

Keep in mind, this is a priest who didn't particularly look forward to celebrating the Latin Mass. And I think he highlights one of the strength of the Catholic Mass, especially the Traditional Latin Mass: it's not about the priest. From what I understand, in Protestant services, the sermon is the center of the service and what people most look forward to and think about later. It's not that way in a properly celebrated Mass. My ex-girlfriend was always surprised by how infrequently I remembered what the homily at Mass was about, but that's because it's not the most important part of Mass: receiving Jesus in the guise of bread and wine is. Even if the priest is an (for example) Indian immigrant who has a thick accent so it's nearly impossible to understand the homily and the ordinary of the Mass is incomprehensible even following along with a missal, it's still a worthwhile experience because of receiving Jesus in the Eucharist. (And, yes, I am thinking of someone specific.) How can any oration, no matter how great, compare to that great gift?

One of the common criticisms of the "new" Mass is that it puts more focus on the priest and encourages showmanship. Some priests faithfully follow the rubrics of the Mass, as they should. Some deviate only slightly, modifying a few words here and there, which is annoying for those of us who like to use missals and pray along with the priest. Some, however, go completely overboard and make the Mass a form of entertainment. I haven't seen anything truly awful, except for the "camel Mass" when I was in Germany. (And I'm vaguely remember something weird at a friend's wedding that made me say "What the hell?") Given that your typical priest isn't going to know Latin that well so he needs to be careful when saying Mass, and he's facing away from the people so there's less temptation towards showmanship, the Latin mass has a strong tendency towards reverence.

Now, the "new" Mass has it's advantages as well: wider use of the Bible in the lectionary, the vernacular is much easier for the people to understand. So, hopefully, and I'd imagine this is Pope Benedict's goal, the two forms will ultimately converge with the nest being taken from each to create a greater experience for all.

Drinking recycled toilet water?

From Sewage, Added Water for Drinking - New York Times

It used to be so final: flush the toilet, and waste be gone.

But on Nov. 30, for millions of people here in Orange County, pulling the lever will be the start of a long, intense process to purify the sewage into drinking water — after a hard scrubbing with filters, screens, chemicals and ultraviolet light and the passage of time underground.

On that Friday, the Orange County Water District will turn on what industry experts say is the world’s largest plant devoted to purifying sewer water to increase drinking water supplies. They and others hope it serves as a model for authorities worldwide facing persistent drought, predicted water shortages and projected growth.

The process, called by proponents “indirect potable water reuse” and “toilet to tap” by the wary, is getting a close look in several cities.

Sometime while Jim Sills was Mayor of Wilmington, I remember him talking about the need to recycle water if a drought continued much longer. The only shocking thing to me is that we weren't already doing that. While I'm sure there's issues around what to do with the waste we remove from the water, it still seems like a no-brainer to me to at least start looking into this. For all the concern about recycling plastic, paper and other items, it seems to me that water is the product we can least afford to run out of and so reusing it might help relieve the burden on our water system.

Cleanliness isn't my biggest concern, but cost:

Although originally estimated at $10 million for the pilot study in San Diego, water department officials said the figure would be refined, and the total cost of the project might be hundreds of millions of dollars. Although the Council wants to offset the cost with government grants and other sources, Mr. Sanders predicted it would add to already escalating water bills.

“It is one of the most expensive kinds of water you can create,” said Fred Sainz, a spokesman for the mayor. “It is a large investment for a very small return.”

I'm used to government contracts being more expensive than originally stated, but this is an order of magnitude off. That's huge. Hopefully, it's the sort of thing that will become cheaper as more water recycling plants come on line.

Quote of the Day: Rudy-Huck '08?

They would balance each other nicely: Put them together, and you've got one conservative.

--Ramesh Ponnuru

Great on-line chat with Bob Novak

Novak on Clinton-Obama, 'Prince of Darkness' - washingtonpost.com

Some highlights:

Toronto: Good afternoon. Why is there such an aversion to paying taxes among conservatives -- how else can a country maintain the infrastructure and services necessary for long-term prosperity?

Robert D. Novak: If you enjoy paying taxes so much, you're more than welcome to pick up mine as well. I think the Treasury would take a check from a Canadian.

...
Kennewick, Wash.: Why should I consider you nonpartisan?

Robert D. Novak: Only because so many Republicans think I am a pain in the neck.

...
Washington: In the past in your column, you have referred to the poor as "losers." This is obviously counter to Catholic teaching on issues of social justice, going back to the 19th century and De Rerum Novarum. How do you reconcile your conversion to Catholicism with your conservative views on issues like social justice?

Robert D. Novak: I follow Scripture and Catholic doctrine rather than the latest theories by the Jesuits and the like.

...
Maryland: Actually the fellow from Toronto had a good question, which you didn't really answer. Why do you think that we can cut taxes and run a real war against terrorism at the same time? At some point, someone has to pay for the several trillion that we have spent on the war and will be spending in the future. Isn't it selfish and short-sighted to put that burden on our children and grandchildren when we can afford to pay the taxes to cover the war now, but just don't want to do so? You certainly can afford the taxes, but don't want to pay. It is just that simple.

Robert D. Novak: Let's be candid. People like you a) always want to raise taxes and b) want to use taxes to redistribute income.
...
Annandale, Va.: Government wastes money that it gets through taxes. In your opinion, is government spending on social causes more wasteful than military spending? I tend to think that both waste funds at same rate and think that we could be just as safe with less military spending.

Robert D. Novak: I agree.

...
New York: As a Catholic, do you think it's a good thing that we have a majority of Catholics on the Supreme Court? Would you be in favor of an all-Catholic/all-Mormon/all-Atheist Supreme Court, or does it not matter?

Robert D. Novak: I wouldn't mind an all-Catholic, all-Jewish or all-Muslim court as long as the justices resembled Roberts, Alito, Scalia and Thomas.

...
St. Paul, Minn.: Do you support capital punishment? If so, how do you reconcile it with your Catholic beliefs. Just as importantly, how do you think the Catholics on the Supreme Court justify it?

Robert D. Novak: There is no Catholic doctrine against capital punishment as there is against abortion.

...
Washington: Where should the limits be in a "limited government"?

Robert D. Novak: The Constitution sets some good ones, though they are largely ignored.

Hat Tip: Memorandum

November 26, 2007

Because I'm a Lunatic...

...I downloaded the songs featured in Scrubs episodes over the years that I actually like from ITunes and created a playlist for my IPod. I'm listening to it right now while testing some code and picturing the scenes where the songs were featured. For example, listening to "Love Hurts" brings to mind images of J.D. (Zach Braff) bouncing up and down making faces of great pain while riding a horse bareback while on his first date with Kim. "More Than a Feeling" has me picturing the hospital's air band performing this song out in the parking lot.

I need help...

Quote-a-palooza

"Liberty must at all hazards be supported." - John Adams

"The Founding Fathers established a system which meant a radical break from that which preceded it. A written constitution would provide a permanent form of government, limited in scope, but effective in providing both liberty and order. Government was not to be a matter of self-appointed rulers, governing by whim or harsh ideology. It was not to be government by the strongest or for the few. Our principles were revolutionary. We began as a small, weak republic. But we survived. Our example inspired others, imperfectly at times, but it inspired them nevertheless. This constitutional republic, conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal, prospered and grew strong. To this day, America is still the abiding alternative to tyranny. That is our purpose in the world- nothing more and nothing less." - Ronald Reagan

"It has become the worst drought in the history of the Southeast. The ground is parched; crops are dying. And last week, Georgia Governor Sonny Perdue decided to do something about it. He urged Georgians to pray for desperately needed rain. Despite much ridicule and some protest, last week, Gov. Perdue led a prayer vigil on the steps of the State Capitol. Praying along with him were pastors from several denominations and hundreds of Georgians. Gov. Perdue may... was following in the steps of our Pilgrim fathers and mothers nearly 400 years ago: Joining together with neighbors for prayer was a familiar ritual for the Pilgrims...[T]he day after Governor Perdue prayed on the Capitol steps, rains swept the state- nearly an inch in places. But the drought has continued...[L]et's remember those in the drought-stricken Southeast and ask the Giver of all good gifts to bless the land with rain." - Chuck Colson

"'To read, or not to read, that is the question.' This was the question posed by the National Endowment for the Arts for a national study about reading habits. The endowment found such a sharp decline of reading that few Americans could recognize Shakespeare's antecedent for the question... Not only are teens and adults reading less, absorbing with shorter attention spans, they're posting diminishing test scores at almost every reading level. Only 9-year-olds are showing better scores, but those are likely to evaporate by the time they're seniors in high school. Gender gaps abound, and in this one, boys are bested by girls, who score 13 points higher than the boys in the 12th grade. There's more at work here than an inability to sit still. In comparisons with 31 industrial nations, our 15-year-olds rank behind those in Poland, Korea, France and Canada, among others. Poor reading spills over into levels of academic achievement. Poor readers are more likely to drop out of school, are more difficult to employ and more likely to swell prison populations. One of the saddest findings in this report is that nearly half of Americans between the ages of 18 and 24 read no books for pleasure. While the electronic media is undoubtedly partly responsible, it doesn't have to be that way." - Suzanne Fields

"In the 1920s and '30s, the American left was riven by multiple factions furiously representing different flavors of socialism, each accusing the others of revisionism and deviationism. Leftists comforted themselves with the thought that 'you can't split rotten wood.' But you can. And the health of a political persuasion can be inversely proportional to the amount of time its adherents spend expelling heretics from the one true (and steadily smaller) church. Today's arguments about conservatism are, however, evidence of healthy introspection... Conservatism is a political philosophy concerned with collective aspirations and actions. But conservatism teaches that benevolent government is not always a benefactor. Conservatism's task is to distinguish between what government can and cannot do, and between what it can do but should not." - George Will

"The United States Postal Service is an anachronism. Yale's law and economics scholar George Priest has characterized it as 'the most significant example of socialism in the United States...[embracing] almost all the aspects of socialism rejected in Eastern Europe and in the privatized Western economies.' It employs 30 percent of the nonmilitary federal workforce; pays wages and benefits 30 percent above competitive levels; and operates more than 60 percent of its offices at a loss. The Postal Service has survived- despite high costs, bland offerings, and comparatively middling service- by exploiting its two statutory monopolies: the carriage of First Class mail; and exclusive access to customer-owned mail boxes." - James Montanye

"Who would respond to criticism from the Club for Growth by calling the conservative, free-market campaign organization the 'Club for Greed'? That sounds like Howard Dean, Dennis Kucinich or John Edwards, all Democrats preaching the class struggle. In fact, the rejoinder comes from Mike Huckabee, who has broken out of the pack of second-tier Republican presidential candidates to become a serious contender- definitely in Iowa and perhaps nationally. Huckabee is campaigning as a conservative, but serious Republicans know that he is a high-tax, protectionist, big-government advocate of a strong hand in the Oval Office directing the lives of Americans. Until now, they did not bother to expose the former governor of Arkansas as a false conservative because he seemed an underfunded, unknown nuisance candidate. Now that he has pulled even with Mitt Romney for the Iowa caucuses with the possibility of more progress, the beleaguered Republican Party has a frightening problem on its hands." - Robert Novak

"There are some people who believe faith doesn't belong in politics. But it does, and it is there inextricably. The antislavery movement, the temperance movement, the civil rights movement, the antiabortion movement, all were political movements animated in large part by religious feeling. It's not that it doesn't matter. You bring your whole self into the polling booth, including your faith and your sense of right and wrong, good and bad, just as presidents bring their whole selves into the Oval Office. I can't imagine how a president could do his job without faith. But faith is also personal. You can be touched by a candidate's faith, or interested in his apparent lack of it. It's never wholly unimportant, but you should never see a politician as a leader of faith, and we should not ask a man whose made his rise in the grubby world of politics to act as if he is an exemplar of his faith, or an explainer or defender of it. We have the emphasis wrong. It's out of kilter. And the result is a Mitt Romney being harassed on radio shows about the particulars of his faith, and Hillary Clinton- a new-class yuppie attorney and board member- announcing how important her Methodist faith is and how much she loves wearing her diamond cross. For all I know, for all you know, it is true. But there is about it an air of patronizing the rubes..." - Peggy Noonan

Pope's New encyclical due Friday

Pope Benedict XVI will release the 2nd encyclical letter of his pontificate, entitled Spe Salvi, on November 30.

The new encyclical, a reflection on the theological virtue of hope, will be formally introduced to the media at a Friday news conference by Cardinal Georges Cottier, the former theologian of the pontifical household; and Cardinal Albert Vanhoye, SJ, the former rector of the Pontifical Biblical Institute.

Looks like my plans for the weekend have been set

Quote of the Day

"Give up money, give up fame, give up science, give the earth itself and all it contains rather than do an immoral act. And never suppose that in any possible situation, or under any circumstances, it is best for you to do a dishonorable thing, however slightly so it may appear to you... From the practice of the purest virtue, you may be assured you will derive the most sublime comforts in every moment of life, and in the moment of death."

-- Thomas Jefferson (letter to Peter Carr, 19 August 1785)

Reference: Jefferson: Writings, Peterson ed., Library of America (814-815)

November 25, 2007

Book Review: Catholicism and Fundamentalism

I started this book a few weeks ago while on retreat and finished it up tonight. It's essentially written in response to anti-Catholic fundamentalists. One thing that surprised me when reading this book is how many prominent non-Catholics repeatedly misrepresent church teaching. (Jerry Falwell is repeatedly cited for doing this; the book was written in 1988.) In the final chapter, Keating quotes Bishop Fulton Sheen as saying "Few hate the Catholic Church,. but millions hate what they. mistakenly think is the Catholic Church". This is certainly true of those who get their ideas of what the Catholic Church believes from anti-Catholics.

For example, my now ex-girlfriend (the Baptist) once showed me an article written by an author claiming to show ten fundamental errors in Catholic theology. A few of these points misrepresented Church teaching to begin with and many others selectively quoted the Bible, ignoring verses that support the Catholic position. Had I been inclined, I could have shown her the verses that refuted the claims made in the article, but it was dinner time and I didn't have the reference materials I needed to find the verses. (I'm generally awful at identifying citations by chapter and verse from memory. Plus, it was time to eat.)

Keating shows the errors made by the anti-Catholics by quoting liberally and frequently from their works, showing their misrepresentation of Catholic belief, whether intentional or otherwise and in fact shows that many of the errors are due to too heavy a reliance on Loraine Boettner's work Roman Catholicism, which is still the "bible" of anti-Catholicism in many ways. Falwell, for example, despite promising his readers that he personally verified every claim he makes about Catholics in one of his works, repeated almost verbatim an error made by Boettner in his work.

This brings up another point Keating and others I've read make: Many Protestants don't really know the Bible; they know the verses that support the position that their pastor taught them. So they sound impressive when they cite chapter and verse, but they can only do that for about 30 verses; outside that, they're in trouble. Keating claims that when you start asking them questions and reviewing the Bible with them asking intelligent questions, they often pull back and return to their pastor.

Again, this lines up with my experience: I was walking to the adoration chapel at St. Ann's once Saturday morning when I bumped into a Jehovah's Witness standing on the sidewalk while another one was approaching a house. The gentleman on the sidewalk stopped me and asked me if I thought my children were safe at school. I told him I didn't have any children, so he asked about my nieces or nephews. I told him I'm an only child. (He was a little amused at that point.) He then asked me if I was aware that the Bible foretold that there would be immorality, war and violence right before the Second Coming. I told him I was, but that was true of all time periods. He then flipped to one of Paul's letters, I guess to show me the verse in context in his Bible. Knowing that the Jehovah's Witness Bible contains some mistranslations, I broke out my Bible which I was carrying in my bag to read while at adoration. When he saw that, he lost interest in talking to me. He clearly wasn't prepared for someone who could respond.

This book gives a good overview of Catholic thought and responses to claim by fundamentalists. It concludes by giving a brief overview in how to defend the faith charitably and honestly when approached by a fundamentalist and also provides reading lists to help Catholics get up to speed on knowing their faith. It's definitely worth reading, and I've heard a number of former Protestants state that it played an important role in bringing them home to the Catholic Church.

We have a new record!

Well over a year after I made the original post, I got a valid comment on my post about Catholics and Beer. So if anyone's interested, there is a Facebook group Catholics for the Moderate Consumption of Beer! Seems like a worthy group.

November 24, 2007

Is this real separation of Church and State?

Lawmakers vow to revise Mexico's constitution to strengthen separation of church, state - MSNBC Wire Services- msnbc.com

And what changes are they making to ensure this separation continues?

Mexico's 1917 constitution guarantees religious freedom of speech and nonreligious public education. But Pages Llergo said it needs to be changed to guarantee that private education is nonreligious, too.

So, in this conception of "separation of church and state," the state is going to tell the church what they can and can't teach in schools.

Mexico has a history of religious intolerance:

Mexico is an overwhelmingly Catholic country, but has a long history of secular government that dates back to the mid-19th century. The country broke relations with the Catholic Church in 1867 and didn't restore them until in 1992, when it also repealed laws that had banned priests from wearing clerical garb in public.

That's sugarcoating it. Mexico's 1857 Constitution outlawed parochial education, closed seminaries and convents, forbade worship outside a church, prohibited religious communities from owning property and priests and nuns from wearing religious garbs, denied clergy the right to vote and the right to criticize the government. Among those opposing these restrictive regulations (and not even Communists behind the Iron Curtain were this oppressive) were called the Cristeros, many of whom ultimately died defending the rights of the Church. Just yesterday the Church commemorated the memory of one of these martyrs, who killed for the offense of being a priest:

Padre Miguel Agustin Pro was one of the best known of the martyred priests. Pro used elaborate disguises so that soldiers would not recognize him as a priest. Known for his indefatigable sense of humor, he visited the faithful often dressed as a beggar. He administered the sacraments, provided jokes and laughter, and helped financially those in need. Rich families often received the sacraments from Padre Pro in his disguise of businessman. Pro and his brother, Humberto, were arrested for being erroneously linked to a car bombing which injured ex-president Obregón. The car used in the bombing was traced back to Humberto Pro, the previous owner.

Calles took advantage of the opportunity to execute a priest publicly in an attempt to discourage other priests from participating in politics. He ordered Pro be shot at the police station and invited reporters to the execution. Padre Pro carried a small crucifix and his rosary and held his arms out forming a cross as he was shot. Pope John Paul II beatified him on September 25, 1988.

Read more about the oppression by the Mexican government at the link above.

It just occurred to me that we shouldn't be surprised at the influx of illegal aliens into America given how the Mexican government has treated its people since gaining independence. The elites in Mexico just don't seem to care about the common person there and haven't for a long time. We need to figure out how to convince Mexican leaders to change.

Quote of the Day

Newly raised Cardinal Daniel DiNardo as quoted in ZENIT:

With regard to the liturgy, I think we can take a cue from the liturgical piety of the Church Fathers. In the Fathers, you see an emphasis not only on the words said at Mass, but also the importance of the gestures of the liturgy. In other words, say the black, do the red.

Hat Tip: The Curt Jester

November 23, 2007

It's Guy Love!

I played this episode of Scrubs for my mom yesterday because I wanted to watch it and she's a Broadway fan. She says she liked it, but I think she was really sad to hear that this song (and "Everything Comes Down to Poo") were nominated for Emmys.

I think my favorite song, though, is "For the Last Time, I'm Dominican":

Second Amendment: An individual, not a collective, right

Mike Cox, Attorney General of Michigan:

The Supreme Court has agreed to take up a case that will affect millions of Americans and could also have an impact on the 2008 elections. That case, Parker v. D.C., should settle the decades-old argument whether the right "to keep and bear arms" of the Constitution's Second Amendment is an individual right--that all Americans enjoy--or only a collective right that states may regulate freely. Legal, historical and even empirical reasons all command a decision that recognizes the Second Amendment guarantee as an individual right.

The amendment reads: "A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed." If "the right of the people" to keep and bear arms was merely an incident of, or subordinate to, a governmental (i.e., a collective) purpose--that of ensuring an efficient or "well regulated" militia--it would be logical to conclude, as does the District of Columbia--that government can outlaw the individual ownership of guns. But this collective interpretation is incorrect.

Quote of the Day

"[T]he great security against a gradual concentration of the several powers in the same department consists in giving to those who administer each department the necessary constitutional means and personal motives to resist encroachment of the others."

-- James Madison (Federalist No. 10, 23 November 1787)

Reference: Madison, Federalist No. 10 (321-22)